PAGE 101 – September 2010

H O T    I D E A S    F O R    S M A L L    R A I L R O A D S

SWITCHING SHELVES IN ALL SCALES
In This IssueZ Scale: Handheld Layout—A working RR in 14.5cm
Z Scale: Tymesaver—Video demo of Z shunting
N Scale: Ruthton—Published plan provides play-value
N Scale: Kidmore Gumstump—Updated version of a classic layout
HOn30 Scale: Smokey Hollow RR—Teenager’s narrow gauge HO line
HO Scale: West Egg—Stand-alone hunk of a large layout
HO Scale: Black Rock, Buffalo—Model REA depot in NY state, USA
HO Scale: Arundale—Railroad action “between the bridges”
OO Scale: Temple Lane—Finescale micro layout features nightlights
O-16.5 Scale: Wheal Tiny—Two-level mine line with a hoist
O Scale: Southwark Park—Big terminal in a small space
1n20 Scale: Gum Stump & Snowshoe—Clever micro Gumstumper
Gn15 Scale: Vulcan Iron Works—Converting an On30 line to Gn15
7/8-Inch Scale: Large Scale Shelf—Seriously BIIIIG trains!

After the Pizza Layout, probably the next most popular design for minimum space
model railways is the Shunting Shelf. It’s a relatively short shelf—often
just four to six feet (1.2 to 1.8 meters) long, designed to pickup and
distribute railway cars among various destinations, returning
eventually to a nearby yard (usually offstage). Simple or complex,
these layouts can keep an operator busy for an hour or more, working out
a single “switching turn.” The basic style is good in any scale, as illustrated by
these examples drawn from all the popular scales in current use.


Z SCALE (1:220, 6.5mm gauge): HERE’S A VERY HAND-Y SHELF
Z Scale layout Z Scale Layout

Tiny Z scale is not usually considered a “switching” scale… but that’s not necessarily true. Here’s a very small shelf, designed to fit in the palm of the hand, by Frédéric Gantier, from Rennes, France.

Frédéric writes, “This Z layout really works, thanks to power supply wires in the thickness of the wooden base connected to an electronic single-line shuttle control, hidden in the industrial building. When the train arrives at one end, infrared beams trigger the circuit to make it go back the other direction. There is a short turntable for switching tipper wagons to the interior line.”

Buildings are scratch-built from Pola kits, tracks and loco come from Märklin, and the boxcar is kitbashed from a Galoob Micro Machines item. The layout measures 14.5x9x3.5cm (5.7×3.5×1.4in). It is packed in a mini plastic box and put in the pocket for transport.


Z SCALE (1:220, 6.5mm gauge): SWITCHING? IN Z-SCALE? OBSERVE!

 

Z scale switching
Still not convinced that reliable switching is possible in Z scale? Here’s impressive proof (right) from Frank Bergmans, who lives in Dommelen, the Netherlands. His work-in-progress (above) is a Tymesaver-style Z layout measuring 95x25cm (37x10in). Frank uses GP locos from MTL, which he believes are the smoothest switchers available. For more, see his website.


N SCALE (1:160, 9mm gauge): PUBLISHED PLAN PROVIDES PLENTY OF PLAY-VALUE
Ruthton Plan Ruthton

Ruthton North, a 52x12in (132x30cm) passenger terminal set in northwest England c. 1955-65 is adapted from a plan by Paul Lunn (redrawn above left). David Richardson’s version (left and below) features a long platform for mainline trains and two short railmotor platforms for commuter traffic. A goods (freight) siding serves a mill, bringing in fuel and exporting finished goods. The fiddle yard (representing the “rest of the world”) fits behind the long mill buildings. David lives near Swindon in Wiltshire, England.
Ruthton   Ruthton


N SCALE (1:160, 9mm gauge): IT’S EASY TO BE GUMSTUMPED IN N SCALE
Gum Stump in N

Gum Stump in N

Kidmore Gumstump, an excellent N scale version of the classic Gum Stump & Snowshoe Railroad, was built by David Mitchell, from Reading, England. David added a few flourishes to the original plan, increasing the number of sidings in the lower yard (at right) and adding a useful runaround loop (passing siding).
Gum Stump in N
The rest of the layout, with its familiar overlapped switchback design, fits neatly into a 4x1ft (120x30cm) shelf. For more information and photographs, see David’s website.


HOn30 SCALE (1:87, 9mm gauge): TEEN’S TRAINS TRANSFORM TABLE TOP
Smokey Hollow RR

Smokey Hollow RR

Sharing his 48x15in (120x38cm) layout under construction is Eldon Hoolsema, aged 15 from Jenison, Michigan, USA. Eldon has been model railroading for several years now, but Smokey Hollow Railroad is his first narrow-gauge line and first micro layout. It illustrates well how much railroading you can do in just a small space, using narrow gauge!

Eldon’s scratchbuilt box cab loco (using a Kato Pocket Line chassis) handles the traffic between the Smokey Hollow Charcoal Co. (being built to fit in the white space at the top center) and the interchange with the main line (off to the right). Also under construction are four charcoal kilns to fit in the brown space beside the main building.


HO SCALE (1:87, 16.5mm gauge): STAND-ALONE PIECE OF A LARGER LAYOUT
West Egg West Egg Plan
West Egg is a minimum-space layout built as an add-on to a much larger basement layout by John Bruce, from Los Angeles, California, USA. Says John, “This part of my layout came as an afterthought: it’s an area next to the water heater and the furnace that I originally hadn’t intended to use. To make things harder, there’s a post that holds up the house running through it. Carl’s site, though, started the juices flowing. I was thinking about building a new micro, but as long as I had some permanent space available, why not figure out how to connect it to the main layout?”

The resulting layout measures 48x22in (120x56cm) and includes an interesting block of business buildings that fit around (and hide) the post (in background of upper left photo). John reports, “The idea here is, as Carl puts it, ‘treating the rest of the layout as a very large fiddle yard.’ A regular switch job works West Egg as a turn from a yard on my main layout, the Los Feliz and North Western. The crew has to make allowances for the trailing and facing point sidings, since there’s no runaround here.”

Highlight of the scenery is the Walthers car float bridge, a “must have” for John. He hasn’t built the car float yet, but the bridge is in place (below, right) and cars are added to it or removed manually. Another good stunt is using the Walthers concrete plant (below, left) as a an industrial backdrop for the layout. All in all, there’s a lot of operation packed into this tiny area, whether it’s operated on its own or as a switching branch of the large layout that provides its fiddle yard!
West Egg   West Egg


HO SCALE (1:87, 16.5mm gauge): BASED ON AN REA DEPOT IN BUFFALO, USA
Black Rock Black Rock
Steve Grantham, from Bubwith, North Yorkshire UK, reports, “Black Rock, Buffalo is based around a small REA depot and attached team tracks. Looking at an old railway map of Buffalo I located an area that could well have had such a depot and, after looking on Google Earth, I found out the area was called Black Rock… Dimensions are 6ft long including fiddleyard by 7 inches wide (180x18cm). The scenic board was originally an N scale layout acquired from a friend!” The fiddle yard is simply a stub track available for manual addition and removal of cars. Works fine in a low-volume, easy-going switching area like this one.
Black Rock   Black Rock


HO SCALE (1:87, 16.5mm gauge): FEATURING ‘BETWEEN THE BRIDGES’ ACTION
Arundale Plan

The prolific Bob Hughes, from Sandbach, Cheshire UK, has done it again. His new HO layout measures 5x1ft (150x30cm) and is called Arundale. Bob describes it thusly: “It is a small, self contained HO layout set somewhere in Conrail territory. The scenery is urban, which I think gives a much more believable reason for a cramped layout. In this case the action is sandwiched between a pair of overbridges, one with a dummy rapid transit station on it and the other carrying a highway.

“The layout is, in true fashion for me, as simple as possible with just a single turnout on stage and the trackwork beyond the bridges being replaced by a pair of hidden traversers. A useful feature of Arundale is that it is ‘flat pack’ for storage and transport.”

Operations on the layout are also typical of Bob’s work, being simple in concept and complex in achievement. He describes the basic idea this way: “Operations involve the incoming trip with one or two cars running round then exchanging these with cars on the industrial spur and RIP track before returning to the fiddle yard. I set myself a time limit before the next passenger train is due then try to get the main line cleared before the RDC arrives.”

Sounds like a lot of fun to be had!
Arundale   Arundale


OO SCALE (1:76, 16.5mm gauge): HARDWORKING RAILROAD RUNS ALL NIGHT
Temple Lane   Temple Lane

Temple Lane

Simon Ward, from York, England, has a photo page (no longer active) of his work-in-progress layout, Temple Lane. Measuring just 3x1ft (90x30cm) plus fiddle yard, it’s his first micro layout. Part of the point is to investigate construction methods, especially using foamcore (foam board), which he says is “very useful stuff indeed!” The layout features nighttime operation and lighting, and is set in the post-privatisation era.


O-16.5 SCALE (1:43.5, 16.5mm gauge): HOIST CONNECTS 2-LEVEL TIN MINE LINE
Wheal Tiny

Stu Hilton, from Truro, Cornwall, England, came up with an unusual bi-level switching shelf. He describes it this way: “Encouraged by Jack Trollope, I created Wheal Tiny, a layout to fit in with the rules of the Wealden Railway Group competition [footprint equal to three sheets of A4 letter paper].

“However, I decided to use 0-16.5 scale/gauge and employ two levels. The layout depicts the ground level and one underground level of a tin mine. The two simple track layouts are joined by a working wagon hoist.”

Elsewhere on this site there are two other bi-level mine layouts using a hoist: Klaus Komischke’s Box File Mine and Carl Arendt’s Almagamated Mine #258.
Wheal Tiny   Wheal Tiny   Wheal Tiny

Wheal Tiny   Wheal Tiny


O SCALE (1:43.5, 32mm gauge): A BIG-CITY TERMINUS IN REALLY SMALL SPACE
Southwark Terminus

Southwark Park is the terminus of a [fictional] short branch line in South London, England. With its connection to the Brighton mainline the station stayed bouyant from its construction in 1869 until its closure during WW1 and subsequent abandonment upon grouping. It is bordered on three sides by warehouses and tenements, and in the cramped location hosts three platform roads, a loco pocket and signal box/lamp-hut.

Will Ayerst, from London, designed the model in ScaleSeven (finescale) O gauge. The track plan is based on Carl Arendt’s HO design, Amalgamated Terminal, and in the larger scale measures 15x2ft (4.5×0.6m) distributed over three modules.

According to Will, “Each staging and platform road is four feet long to accomodate a large tender locomotive and two bogie passenger carriages, or a smaller tender locomotive and three 26-foot carriages, and so on. The layout is trisected by a tunnel and a road bridge which should ensure that no full train is viewable in any section at once, thereby hiding the under-scale length of trains hauled by larger locomotives.” Despite the layout’s small size, minimum radius is 6½ feet and minimum turnout size is #6 including a 1:6 double-slip switch.

As for operation, Will comments, “Operation will be more in the ‘play’ manner than prototypical, befitting the freelanced track plan and location. Push-pull workings will simply call at the station and reverse out (for a similar example, see Greenwich Park Station). Services from London Bridge, Bricklayers Arms, Croydon or further afield will need to have their carriages removed by the station pilot for them to be released to the nearby shed for turning and servicing (for a similar example, see: Central Croydon). The carriages will then be returned to an outbound road for the locomotive to re-couple and depart for distant cities.”

This would be an amazing road featuring finescale modelling of passenger service in an extremely small space.
Southwark Terminus


#1n2 SCALE (1:32, 16.5mm gauge): A PORTABLE, GUMSTUMP LAYOUT IN LARGE SCALE
1/32 Gum Stump and Snowshoe   1/32 Gum Stump and Snowshoe
Inspired by Alexander Lehmann’s clever, compacted micro version of the Gum Stump & Snowshoe RR, this tiny layout is under construction in 1:32 scale by Les Coleman, from Maresfield, East Sussex England. Les started by aiming at the Wealden Railway Group’s 3xA4 layout challenge (described above), but when those plans fell through he was hooked and has continued work on the layout.

Les comments, “The building housing the hand-operated two-level traverser is a foamcore mock up which will be replaced shortly. I puzzled for some time about how to hold the vertical traverser in the uppermost position before hitting on the solution. The traverser can turn on the vertical rod as well as move up and down on it. At the top position I swivel the traverser by a few degrees—about half an inch at the ends—and settle it on fixed supports at each end. When I want to lower the traverser, I swivel it back again slightly and lower it using the handle (see lower left photo).

“As befits an industrial setting, the track is planned to be inset, which is still unfinished. The stock shown is 1:32 scale, although it can also handle Gn15 trains.” All in all, this is an ingenious micro layout based on a classic small-layout design!
1/32 Gum Stump and Snowshoe   1/32 Gum Stump and Snowshoe


Gn15 SCALE (1:22.5, 16.5mm gauge): CONVERTING FROM O TO LARGE SCALE N.G.
Vulcan Iron Works

Changing scales on his layout (sometimes called “rubber gauging”) is Franck Combe, from Asniéres-sur-Seine (suburban Paris), France. Franck is switching from On30/Oe (at right) to Gn15 scale (1:22.5 or thereabouts) (below). Interestingly, very few changes are required in the track plan, just the scenery.
Vulcan Iron Works   Vulcan Iron Works


7/8-INCH SCALE (1:13.7, 45mm gauge): THE ULTIMATE MODELERS’ SCALE?
7/8-inch scale layout

Probably the largest of the indoor switching shelf scales is 7/8-inch to the foot, which uses G-scale track (45mm wide) to represent two-foot gauge! These are really BIG trains, built essentially board-by-board, just like the real ones are. A long, narrow shelf is about all that can be accommodated in an average home in this scale!

These photos of Simon Harris’s exhibition shelf, which measures about 10×1.4ft (3×0.5m), provide a feeling for the size and heft of these delightful models. The detail can’t be beat! Simon also makes and sells a range of modeling supplies for this big scale under the trade name Modelearth Design. Thanks to Gerry Snelson for calling this layout to our attention!
7/8-inch scale layout   7/8-inch scale layout



Carl Arendt

Webmaster Carl Arendt died on March 4, 2011 in Olympia, Washington. Carl came to Pittsburgh to attend Carnegie Mellon where he graduated with a degree in physics and met Sheila, his wife of 49 years. Carl started work for Westinghouse Electric Corporation where he spent his entire career. During this time, he and Sheila raised their three sons. Following retirement from Westinghouse, Carl threw himself into the world of micro-railroading. In 2002 he started this web site, and authored three books on the subject. This web site attracted a large worldwide following, and Carl built up a collection of friends who came to know and respect him even though most had never met him in person. Such was his personality that it shone through across the ether. He and Sheila moved to Olympia in 2009 to be close to their son Giles and his family, where Carl enjoyed time with his three grandchildren. His wit, erudition, and creativity made this true gentleman a joy to be with, in both the real and the virtual world. This site is a trove of microlayout ideas and examples, and so long as it continues will keep Carl's memory alive and further the hobby he loved.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

mautic is open source marketing automation